More
    Home Blog Page 58

    The New FIFA Agent Regulations: Explained

    0

    Introduction

    After years of debate and discussion between FIFA and other football governing bodies since the deregulation of agents in 2015, the new era of football agent regulations has begun. Today, the 9th of January, 2023, marks the first day of which the newest FIFA Football Agent Regulations (FFAR) comes into force. The major points to note for these new regulations concern caps placed upon commission fees, the new centralised FIFA clearing house system, the prohibition of multiple representation and the updated licensing system which includes the requirement of passing an exam devised and internationally distributed by FIFA.

    In this blog, we will provide a comprehensive and clear guide as to everything that an agent needs to be aware of with the new FFAR implementation. It is absolutely vital that agents that are already in the industry and those wishing to become a part of it, have a complete understanding of the implications that the new regulations will have for them and how to adhere to them to avoid legal issues and other problems throughout their career.

    Licensing and the Exam

    According to the new FFAR, there are several steps that must be adequately completed in order for a candidate to obtain their licence to operate as an agent. These core steps are as follows:

    1. Comply with eligibility criteria

    An applicant must first complete a licensing application via the FIFA or National Association platform. Part of this process outlines the eligibility requirements that a candidate must comply with. This includes details such as possessing no criminal record and other ‘proper persons tests’.

    NOTE: These requirements must also remain to be complied with throughout the entire period of time that the individual operates as an agent. Failure to do so will result in a revocation of an agent’s licence.

    These eligibility requirements are set out below:

    • No false or misleading statements within the candidate’s application.
    • Zero criminal charges and convictions regarding all matters.
    • Must not be a recipient of a suspension, disqualification or striking off order by a sporting governing body or regulatory authority.
    • No record of failure to comply with rules relating to ethics and professional conduct.
    • Must not be an official or employee of FIFA, a confederation, National Association, League, Club or any body that represents the interests of clubs. (The only exception to this is where an applicant has been appointed or elected to a body of one of these entities in a capacity of representing the interests of Football Agents).
    • Must not hold any interest in a club, academy or league.
    • Must not have been performing the services of a football agent without a licence prior to submitting their application.
    • Must never have been personally bankrupt or been a majority shareholder in a business that declared bankruptcy, entered administration or undergone liquidation.
    • Must not have been a part of a sports betting company or organisation in the year preceding the application.

    Compliance with these requirements will be investigated and regulated by FIFA themselves.

    1. Pass the exam

    FIFA’s new regulations demand that individuals wishing to obtain an agency licence must pass the newly formatted exam. The exam will be open-book but is only available in the three main football languages; English, Spanish and French. The must-know details of the agent exam are summarised below:

    • Candidates that are confirmed as eligible will be invited to attempt the examination in their National Association allocated venue.
    • Candidates may have to pay a fee to take the exam.
    • FIFA will set the dates and frequency of the exams for candidates. It is currently understood that there will be two a year in March and September. The first exam will take place on the 19th April 2023. The deadline to apply for this will be the 15th March.
    • The exam is structured as 20 multiple choice questions to be answered in 60 minutes (3 minutes per question). They will ask candidates to consider different scenarios and case studies and require you to select the single best answer to each question or situation. The pass mark is yet to be officially stated but it is expected to be 75% or 15 correct answers out of a possible 20.
    • The questions will be based upon FIFA legislation only rather than specific national association laws. The six key documents that will be covered are as follows:

    1. FIFA’s agent regulations: As discussed previously, these are all the new regulations that have been implemented as well as those that are still relevant and applicable from previously. This covers everything from commission and representation contracts to representing youth players and exclusivity. It is expected that 15 of the possible 20 questions will be based on these regulations, whilst the remaining five questions are based on the below.

    2. Regulations of the Status and Transfer of Players (RSTP): This is the most important of FIFA documents that outlines registration of players, contractual matters, compensation, third party influence and jurisdictions.

    3. FIFA Statutes: Details the legislation and general rules and regulations for the operations of FIFA.

    4. FIFA Code of Ethics: This outlines rules of conduct within football as well as the sanctions and disciplinary measures that can arise from it. It also includes the procedures and methods of adjudication in disputes.

    5. FIFA Disciplinary Code (FDC): A wider and more intricate report regarding various disciplinary sanctions and infringements from doping and assault to forgery and corruption. It also explains the various bodies and organisations involved in sanction procedures.

    6. FIFA Guardians – Child Safeguarding Toolkit: Refers to education on the protection of minors and players.

    Note: For agents that passed the previous exam that was conducted prior to the deregulation in 2015, they will not be required to sit the new exam but they are required to continue to meet annual educational requirements outlined by FIFA. For agents who have obtained their licence after 2015 and wish to continue to operate, they will be given until the 1st October 2023 to pass the exam and adhere to the newest licensing system.

    1. Pay the licensing fee

    This fee will now be paid directly to FIFA rather than to a national association. Therefore, the fee is also standardised and universally set by FIFA (this has not been specified as yet). Failure to pay the annual licensing fee will nullify a candidate’s status as an agent or they will not receive their licence in the first place.

    1. Receive the licence

    This grants the ability to conduct football agent services. This will then remain valid as long as  the candidate continues to meet the eligibility criteria and the annual fees. Additionally, FIFA is introducing a Continuing Professional Development (CPD) education system which requires the agent to annually demonstrate that they are maintaining and updating their level of knowledge of relevant regulations to continue to possess a valid licence.

    Note: The processes listed above will come into force on the 9th January for obtaining a licence. However, FIFA has facilitated for a ‘transition period’ for football agents that already have their licence. This provides a window until the 1st October 2023. By this time, it will be mandatory that any agents used in a transaction must be licensed under the new FFAR and sufficiently capped as explained in the next section.

    Commission Caps and the FIFA Clearing House

    As part of the new regulations, FIFA have installed commission caps, primarily to keep as much money as possible in the game. The hard commission restrictions implemented by FIFA for agent services in a single transaction are as follows:

    Source: FIFA Football Agent Regulations

     

    Putting the table into simple terms:

    1. Individual refers to the agent acting on behalf of the player (the individual) as the client. If the player’s annual remuneration is above $200,000 (or the same amount in another currency), the agent is entitled to 3% of this figure. If it is below $200,000, the agent is entitled to 5%.
    2. The engaging entity simply means the ‘buying club’. If the player’s annual salary is above $200,000, the agent is entitled to 3% of this figure from the buying club; or 5% if it is below $200,000.
    3. If prior written consent has been given by each party, and the agent represents both the player and the buying club (the only permitted form of multiple representation) the commission percentage is doubled. If the player earns less than $200,000 annually, the agent is entitled to 10% of this, 5% from the player and 5% from the club. If the salary is over $200,000, the agent is entitled to 6% (3% from the buying club, 3% from the player).
    4. Finally, if the agent represents the selling club (releasing entity) as their client, they will be entitled to 10% of the transfer compensation, regardless of the individual’s remuneration.

    Note: if there are multiple agents involved in one service provision, this does not entitle the agent to a commission fee any more than the relevant capped percentage in total.

    Additionally to the implementation of commission caps and in the interest of enhancing the financial transparency of all global transfers and transactions that take place, FIFA have developed and established a centralised ‘Clearing House’. The clearing house requires that all transactions within the football transfer system to be passed through and documented by this single and universal clearing house. Hence, agent commission fees and remuneration will also be paid directly from here.

    Multiple Representation

    Part of the FFAR addresses multiple representation and aims to combat the issues of conflict of interests and other moral and legal questions that were previously raised through the practice. The changes made by FIFA are as follows:

    1. An intermediary should only perform his/her services on behalf of one party. There is only ONE exception to this rule (2)
    2. The agent can legally act on behalf of the individual player and the engaging club ONLY if the following criteria is met:
    3. Both parties are made aware of the conflict of interests that will arise as a result.
    4. The details of both contracts, including the terms of service and the terms of remuneration are fully disclosed to each party.
    5. Both parties have the right to seek independent legal advice on the matter.
    6. The player must have a pre-existing representation contract with the agent, lodged with the National Association.
    7. This means that the agent is not entitled to simultaneously represent the buying club and the selling club; the selling club and the player; nor ALL THREE PARTIES.

    First and foremost, the primary purpose of these new regulations is to prevent instances where the agent was able to represent all three parties. They also minimise the conflicts of interest that would occur in dual representation agreements. FIFA suggested these changes as a sign of intent to achieve the fundamental principles that must be met in order to improve the football industry and to increase the transparency of agents and transactions. Instead of relying upon National Associations to make their own judgements on dual representation, FIFA has attempted to synchronise and coordinate the regulations to create a more robust and consistent system. The new regulations incur sanctions and penalties if they are violated and if an agent is found to have committed a ‘misconduct offence’.

    Note: Penalties include punishments such as loss of remuneration for the agent from affected parties and potentially the revokement of a licence to operate.

    Unchanged but Important Regulations to Know

    As well as the major new regulations that have been implemented. The rest of the FFAR also contains regulations that are vital to be aware of. Some of the most significant of these are summarised below:

    1. National football associations will have until the 30th September 2023 to implement and enforce their own agent regulations. However, FIFA can also request that they be submitted for review before they are passed to ensure they adhere to the FFAR.
    2. Agent services may only be performed for a client having entered into a written Representation Agreement.
    3. A representation agreement is limited to a duration of a maximum of 2 years. Automatic renewal clauses are prohibited.
    4. An agent’s approach to a minor in relation to football agent services may only be made no more than six months before the minor reaches the age at which they may sign their first professional contract and as long as prior written consent has been obtained by the legal guardian.
    5. An agent may not approach a client that is already bound by an exclusive representation agreement with another football agent before the final two months of the existing contract.
    6. The FIFA Disciplinary Committee and Ethics Committee are responsible for imposing sanctions for any infringements on the regulations.

    We hope that this is a useful summary to everyone that is researching the FIFA Football Agent Regulations that came into force today. Below we have recommended some further reading:

    To read a more in-detail exploration of the new FIFA Agent exam, click here.

    Importance of Languages for Football/Soccer Agents: Most important Languages and What Agents Need to Know in Spanish

    0

    In this blog, we will discuss the importance of languages in football, with more emphasis towards the second most important language, Spanish. Next, we are going to introduce a list of words and phrases that are essential for agents who want to operate in the Spanish and Latin markets.

    Spanish 101 for Football Agents

    Regarding Football Contracts:

    English Spanish
    Player Jugador
    Youth Player Jugador Juvenil
    Agent Agente
    Club Club de Fútbol
    Contract Contrato
    Employment Contract Contratación Laboral
    Mandate Mandato
    Signature Firma
    Registration Registro
    Written Escrito
    Transfer Transferencia
    Loan Préstamo
    Representation Contract Contrato de Representación
    Sporting Director Director Deportivo
    Owner Dueño del Equipo
    President Presidente
    Head Coach/Manager Director Técnico/Entrenador
    Salary Sueldo
    Bonus Bono
    Signing on fee Pago al firmar
    Insurance Seguro Médico
    Loyalty Bonus Bono de Fidelidad
    Image Rights Derechos de Imagen
    Sponsorship Patrocinios
    Gross Salary Sueldo Bruto
    Net Salary Sueldo Neto
    Commission Comisión
    Agreement Acuerdo/Contrato
    Solidarity Payment Pago de Solidaridad
    Training Compensation Indemnización por Formación
    Academy Academia
    Mutual Agreement Contract Termination Vencimiento de Contrato por Mutuo Acuerdo
    Termination due to Just Cause Recisión de Contrato por Causa Justificada
    Buyout Clause Cláusula de Recisión
    Release Clause Cláusula de Liberación
    Termination Terminación

    All Positions On The Field:

    English Spanish
    Goalkeeper Arquero, Portero
    Centre Back Defensa Central
    Left Back/Right Back Lateral Izquierdo/Lateral Derecho
    Defensive Midfielder Mediocentro Defensivo/Pivote
    Midfielder Mediocentro/Centrocampista
    Left Midfield/Right Midfield Interior/Volante Izquierdo – Interior/Volante Derecho
    Attacking Midfielder Mediapunta/Mediocentro Ofensivo
    Left Wing/Right Wing Extremo Izquierdo/Extremo Derecho
    Striker Delantero
    Centre Forward Delantero Centro
    Second Striker Segunda Punta/Segundo Delantero

    General Knowledge:

    English Spanish
    Appearance Aparición/es
    Team Equipo
    Score Marcador
    Win Ganar
    Draw Empatar
    Lose Perder
    Playing Time Tiempo/Minutos de juego
    National Team Selección Nacional
    Official Games Partidos Oficiales
    Registration Period Periodo de Inscripción
    Registration Request Solicitud de Inscripción
    Season Temporada
    Football Passport Pasaporte Deportivo
    Loan Transfer Transferencia a Préstamo
    Performance Rendimiento
    Goal Gol
    Assist Asistencia
    Penalty Penalti
    First Half Primer Tiempo
    Half-Time Entretiempo
    Second Half Segundo Tiempo
    Corner Saque de Esquina
    The Near Post Primer Palo
    The Far Post Segundo Palo
    Counterattack Contraataque
    Throw-In Saque de Banda
    Booked Amonestado
    Foul Falta/Infracción
    Yellow Card Tarjeta Amarilla
    Red Card Tarjeta Roja
    Sent off Expulsado
    Free Kick Tiro Libre
    Defend Defender
    Attack Atacar
    Substitute Suplente
    Offside Fuera de Juego
    To Shoot Pegarle/Disparar
    Pitch Cancha/Campo
    Squad Plantel
    Kick off Comenzar/Arracncar
    High Ball Game Juego Aéreo
    Changing Room Vestuario
    Bench Banquillo
    Handball Mano

    Phrases

    English Spanish
    “I want to propose you a player” “Le quiero proponer un jugador”
    “I need more playing time for my player” “Necesito más tiempo de juego para mi jugador”
    “What is the score?” “Cuanto va el Partido?”
    “How much time is left?” “Cuanto tiempo queda/resta?”
    “Which positions are you looking for?” “Que posiciones estas buscando?”
    “Do you want to sell players?” “Estas buscando vender jugadores?”
    “Do you have some players on loan?” “Tienes algún jugador en préstamo?”
    “Do you have any player looking to go on loan?” “Tienes algún jugador para ir a un equipo como préstamo?/En condición de prestamo?”
    “Which substances count towards doping?” “Que substancias cuentan cómo doping?”
    “Have your player done any doping test?” “Su jugador se ha hecho algún estudio de doping?”
    “Do you work in media?” “Usted trabaja como periodista?”
    “Do you want to have an interview with my player?” “Le gustaría tener una entrevista con mi jugador?”

    Conclusion

    Languages are definitely one of the main tools that agents need to be able to operate fluently and effectively in different markets around the world. In addition to being of great help on contractual issues, languages serve to connect in a deeper and more genuine way with international players and their families. In this blog, we highlighted the importance of languages for agents and made a complete list of some of the most used words in the world of football in the Spanish language. Additionally, we included some phrases that can be useful for agents traveling to a foreign country in which the native language is Spanish. This enables agents to have the possibility of communicating and understanding the players, the game, and what is happening around the field.

    The Winter Transfer Window – A Football/Soccer Agent’s Perspective

    0

    Introduction

    In a previous episode of this series concerning the world of agents, we assessed the summer transfer window through the lens of an agent. As the winter holidays have come and gone and we move into a new year, in most countries around the footballing globe, the winter transfer window has opened.

    By name and by concept, the summer transfer window and the winter transfer window may be placed into the same bracket. However, the reality is that these two windows take on starkly different characteristics. In this blog we will once again take the perspective of an agent in approaching and operating within the winter transfer window and highlight the biggest contrasts with the summer equivalent.

    The Winter Transfer Window

    The winter transfer window occurs across different national football associations over different time periods. These are outlined in the graphic below:

    As you can see, for most national associations, the winter transfer window takes place during the middle of the season and often in the month of January. I will detail the exceptions to this later on in the blog. Inevitably, as the window lasts only a month rather than spanning across three months, business is slower and there is a significant difference in the volume of deals that take place in the winter window compared with the summer, pre-season window. This is reflected in the graph below which shows the disparity between the spending of the top 5 European leagues in the summer and winter windows. These are typical figures taken from before the impact of COVID-19 dramatically altered the financial expenditure in transfer windows:

    Another factor which creates a more stagnant market is that clubs are typically more reluctant to spend significant sums of money on major transfers mid-season unless there is a drastic urgency. There are, as is the case in most aspects of football, exceptions that go against this general pattern. For example, Ferran Torres moved from Manchester City to Barcelona for a fee of around €55million in the January window of the 2021-22 season. It is important for agents not to dismiss transfer opportunities and to ignore this as an option entirely as the football market is unpredictable and if a club is desperately interested in a specific player, there is no law preventing them pursuing a deal in the winter window.

    Nevertheless, the common pattern in the winter window is that the kind of opportunity that clubs are looking for are loan deals. One way in this materialises is a club that is looking for a particular player profile or position to join the squad until the end of the season. Perhaps this may be to replace a long-term injured player or to fill a glaring gap in the current squad. Targeting loan deals means that the club can patch over the urgent need for now and then carry out a thorough investigation leading up the summer window and finding a permanent solution.

    The Role of the Agent

    As an agent, you can begin to assess and predict how the winter window may play out well before it opens. It is very common for discussions to happen and offers to be made well before January. The best agents have an in-depth knowledge of the current football market and will be able to make fairly accurate estimates as to the kind of player, or at least the position, which clubs will be looking for when the window does begin. Constantly and relentlessly monitoring the market benefits your savviness as an agent. You can identify club needs that link with particular players that you are able to access or even your own clients and you can make the deal happen. This will also enhance your reputation and relationship with clubs as you will approach them with a purpose and a preexisting understanding that they are likely to be interested in your opportunity.

    It is better to approach a club with a meaningful opportunity rather than to be seen as wasteful of their time. For example, you may have spotted that a club has two central-defenders injured and another hasn’t quite been performing at the required standard in the lead up to the January transfer window. Furthermore, there aren’t an abundance of academy-graduate options available to them that they can trust at first-team level. This club is unlikely to be prioritising strikers as they have had no trouble in the goals department and their attacking options have been playing well. It is futile to offer this club a forward player but the chances are, they will be interested in bolstering their defensive options until at least the end of the season. This can present an opportunity for you as an agent to broker deals and perhaps for a client to find a loan move. The best case scenario could be that you are able to bring a client on a loan deal in the winter window with an option or obligation to buy at the end of the loan included in the contract. If your client impresses at the new club and fills the void they needed, this can then materialise into a permanent transfer, perhaps in the following summer window bringing you additional income and will be appreciated by your client.

    Alternatively, a club may be more concerned with offloading players from their squad in order to enhance their match fitness and experience. This is particularly the case with younger players in squads who are still developing and adjusting to men’s football. Clubs tend to be willing to source suitable loan deals for these players if they have not been able to give them consistent game time in the first half of the season. If you are the agent of such a player, you need to assess whether this is a positive career step for the client.

    Serving the Client and the Club

    Often, your role will be to offer your services to the club, as well as your client, in finding a loan agreement that best serves the interests of the client. You will need to consider the standard of the football at the prospective clubs as well as their coaching system. In some cases, it may actually be favourable to try to avoid a loan if the player is developing well at the current club and is flourishing under the coaching staff. Unfortunately, it can sometimes be the case that a loan move is too much of a step down in level for young players and this stalls their development. It can be better for them to stick with the higher club, learn from the coaches and the better players around them and make the most of the game time and opportunities they do get. However, my advice would be that in most cases, a loan move is a good option for a young player if they are struggling to break into the first team at their current club. It will expose them to a greater experience of mens football and at a young age, this is the best time for their development so it is important that they are playing football.

    As the agent, you need to understand your client, their style of play and their interests well. This knowledge will not only enable you to find a club in which the player will be able to flourish but also will ensure that they are happy with the move themselves. If the system at the club is not one that will suit your client nor are they particularly motivated in moving there, this can create an issue and the second half of the season can be wasted if you commit to a flawed loan move in the winter window. A loan deal mid-season needs to be carefully considered and communicated with the clubs and the player.

    Another important factor to be aware of is the performance and success of the club in the first half of the season. This can often indicate and hint at what  their intentions might be in the winter window. Some clubs may be very content with their season thus far and are pushing above their expectations and are not in any kind of hurry to find new players. However, as well as clubs that have had injury problems, the most likely to be looking for players in the winter windows are ones that are either pushing for trophies or promotion, or those that are set to be involved in a relegation battle. These are two, very different, desperate situations.

    For those facing relegation, a push in the January window can help them bring in one or two key players that can make the difference in keeping the club from going down. They may also have had a change in manager before the winter window, who is implementing a new system at the club to try and change their fortunes and needs the right players added to the squad to carry out their plans. At the top end of the table, the clubs that are targeting promotion, play-offs, European qualification or maybe even the title, may have a couple of areas which they believe, if improved, could help them get over the finish line where they want. Identifying the clubs that fit into these categories can also help you as the agent to narrow down the opportunities that may be available to you and your clients if they suit what the club is looking for.

    The key is to be smart and savvy. The window is short but it can also be very busy if you have the nous to identify and seek out the most favourable opportunities for you and clients. Use your contacts and knowledge of clubs to analyse the market and carry out due diligence well in advance of the window. This increases your chances of being active and successful in a slow January window.

    The ‘Winter’ Window in The Americas

    As I mentioned, the winter window, in the majority, is a shortened mid-season window to allow clubs to make quick and often temporary adjustments to their squads before completing the second half of the season. However, there are exceptions to this and this is the case in two major markets, Brazil and the US. In these national associations the ‘winter’ window usually doesn’t open until the end of January as it closes in others. This is because it is a pre-season window, just like the summer window elsewhere as the timings of their playing seasons are different. Hence, these windows are also around 3 months long and will remain open until the latter stages of april.

    The implications of this for an agent is that if you are not based in these regions, once the January window is closed, you should not stop working. There are two major football markets that are just opening for business so it is an opportunity that should not be missed. It is vital that you consider and plan some potential deals that may present themselves by looking into these markets. This falls under the advantage of being a global agent. Having connections in each corner of the football globe can help you to access deals and sources of income, even when the main transfer windows are closed.

    It is vital to be aware that if the window is shut in European markets for example, the player is not able to sign into a club in these regions but they are able to leave. Consequently, as the agent you can still move a client into a window that is still open even if they are transferring from one that is now closed. This is a significant factor in finding a next step for your client and possibilities that are available even when the window is shut in their current market.

    In these markets, you can speak with contacts and clubs as well as carrying out your own research to find whether there is any potential for you to conduct business during the winter pre-season window. You have three months to find clubs that are looking to improve their personnel before the beginning of their campaign for the year. It could be an exciting possibility to move a client abroad and to an upcoming and thriving market such as the MLS in the US. If your client is dissatisfied with their current situation, they will appreciate that you continue to work for them even after the usual windows are shut and are trying to find them a new beginning in a new league and country.

    Summary

    Perhaps it is needless to say that in order to operate as an agent in football, you ought to have a wide-ranging and extensive knowledge of the markets and transfer windows. There are major points of difference between the summer and winter windows and I hope that this blog has demonstrated the nuances you need to work around in order to successfully conduct business in the January winter window. However, this blog has also highlighted that there are opportunities beyond this traditional January window and further afield. Finding the best opportunity for your clients, no matter where in the world, should be the priority and along the way there will also be the chance to broker deals and to work alongside clubs, further improving and expanding your capabilities as an agent.

    The Pandemic of Football/Soccer Player Trafficking and the Exploitation of Minors

    0

    Introduction

    In this week’s blog we return to focus on the wider world of football and to cover a poignant topic that we feel is very important for football fans, professionals and anyone involved in the sport to be aware of. Having travelled to locations such as Nigeria, Ghana, Kenya and Brazil and having looked into this specific issue, it is a problem that resonates significantly with Dr Erkut Sogut and one that we feel passionately about.

    This blog aims to explain the pandemic of youth exploitation that is rife within modern football and to raise awareness of the issue in order to encourage active campaigns to prevent it being a problem that continues into the future of football. Human trafficking in football and the exploitation of minors is a difficult and sensitive topic to discuss but it is an unavoidable issue and without discussion, the chances of ending the illegal and immoral practice will fade.

    Article 19 of the FIFA RSTP

              FIFA’s Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players (RSTP) contain a clause that directly addresses the protection of minors. Article 19(1) states that the international transfer of a player under the age of 18 is prohibited unless the circumstances meet the exceptions listed in article 19(2).

              The exceptions to the illegality of the international transfer of minors given in article 19(2) are:

    1. The player’s parents move to a different country for reasons unrelated to football and the player follows them.
    2. The player is over 16 and the move takes place between two countries that are members of the European Union. Furthermore for this exception, the receiving club must have provided written proof that they have satisfied the criteria and expectations of FIFA to provide education beyond football, football training and an agreeable standard of living including accommodation provision and mentorship.
    3. The player lives within 50km of the border of the other country.

              Importantly, the list of exceptions provided here are not exhaustive and FIFA has stated that exemptions can also be granted for circumstances where the player is a refugee and has moved for humanitarian reasons. The clause extends to and applies to players that have not previously registered with a club and are not a national citizen of the country they are moving to; although this is the demographic that is often exploited as we will look into later. FIFA requires that all youth international transfer cases should pass through the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) which will judge permission on a case by case basis.

              The aim of article 19 of the FIFA RSTP and the enforcement of CAS is to uphold the safety and protection of minors. It is a prevention mechanism that was implemented for the right reasons. Unfortunately, despite its intention, the regulations have so far been unable to prevent the recent surge in ‘football trafficking’ that has become a worryingly prevalent practice in modern football.

    What is Football Trafficking?

    In short, football trafficking refers to the human trafficking and exploitation of minors from one country to another under the pretence that they will receive lucrative footballing opportunities. The most common materialisation of football trafficking is usually the transfer of players under 18 years of age between third world countries and poorer regions such as Africa or South America to developed and football-rich European countries such as France and Italy.

              The literacy rates in the South American and African countries are low and many youth players and their parents are uneducated. Hence, they are unaware of the signs that would indicate they are being exploited. They are often targeted by people who are considered as ‘fake agents’ or other unlicensed and unregulated representatives sometimes referred to as ‘managers’ in African countries. These individuals claim to have legitimate links with football clubs in Europe and will promise a player an opportunity to trial with them and have a successful career in the sport.

    The agents are usually employed as part of an underworld organisation in football that has a vast network that profits from exploiting youth footballers in this way. The managers will forge passports, visas, letters and other documents as well as offering gifts such as football boots and clothing in order to gain the trust of the families and build an image of themselves as reputable and legitimate. In some extreme cases, it has been known for agents to photoshop images to show to the player that appears to be them with famous footballers and managers to entice the player and their family further.

              For many people in these regions, the temptation of a football career in Europe is often too great to resist. The families often believe that by making the move to Europe in pursuit of the promises the fake agent has made, will mean that the player can send money back to the family and they will escape their life of poverty and struggle. The scam materialises when it comes to moving to Europe and the agent asks the family for money to transport the player for the opportunity. The sad reality is that families may sometimes sell land or use any means possible to raise money, or even the surrounding community will contribute and generate the necessary funds to help the player chase the dream they are being promised. What happens next can vary but there are usually the following possible outcomes:

    1. The first way that this then materialises is that the player never actually gets anything in return for the money they have paid. They pay the scam agent before they disappear and the player is unable to retrieve the money that themselves, their family and other supporters raised in order to pursue their dream that was sold to them by the so-called agent.
    2. In other cases, the player will actually be shipped over to Europe by whatever means they were able to afford from the money given to the agent. This can often be thousands of dollars but may be as treacherous as having to cross with refugees and migrants on small and dangerous rafts. Then either:
    1. Once the player has arrived in Europe, there may be someone waiting for them to ‘look after’ them. It usually quickly becomes apparent that there is either no trial or opportunity or the trials they are given are with teams from lower divisions and any money they ultimately make will be kept by the scam agents rather than benefiting themselves. These associates that meet the player in Europe will usually house the players themselves and have numerous minors living with them who have emigrated from their homes under the same false promises. However, as the associate and the fake agent possess their documents, passports and money, they are able to control them and continue to take money from them. If the player is able to play at a higher level, the original fake agent and the associate will disappear to ensure that their operation is not made public. This is why these individuals are sometimes referred to as ‘ghost agents’. They will often return to Africa or South America and find the next player to be trafficked and to receive money from.

    Or

    1. Wherever the player lands, no one is there to meet them. They will be left completely abandoned and forced to find their own way home. This is usually in countries such as Cyprus, the middle-east, European countries but also the main exit points from Africa such as Addis Ababa in Ethiopia. For those that become stuck, they are minors and this can make it very difficult for them to return home. Lack of finances, language barriers, inability to access communication with their families and embarrassment or shame can be factors that prevent these youth players from being able to return to their home country after this has happened. Many will end up homeless in the new country, will have to seek low paid jobs to try to make a living or may resort to a life of criminality themselves. In some cases, they will lose contact with their families completely and their lives will have been ruined by an agent that has scammed and exploited the player and their family.      
    2. Another terrifying possibility for when the player arrives in Europe is that they will be exploited for various other things rather than low-level football trials. These can often be criminal activities such as being forced into illegal gangs or even into sex slavery and can happen in almost any city in the world.

    This is not a small problem as the statistics show, In Africa alone, an average of over 6,000 players are trafficked to Europe every year according to Foot Solidaire. The majority of these are minors, ambitious to follow in the footsteps of the likes of Sadio Mane, Samuel Eto’o, Didier Drogba and the Toure brothers. They are cruelly misled and lied to by fake agents seeking to make easy money from what they force the families to pay them before they abandon their child in a foreign country. The worldwide number stands at around 15,000 minors trafficked globally every year.

    Prevention and Loopholes

              Despite article 19 of the FIFA RSTP explicitly prohibiting any activity of the exact nature that I have described in the previous section, the practice continues to be a prevalent issue in modern football. The most high profile case in recent years was that of Atlético Madrid in 2016. The La Liga club was charged with 201 breaches of article 19 in activity that involved 221 minors over the previous seven years. It was revealed that the Spanish footballing giant had created a third party ‘feeder system’ which it believed exploited a loophole in the regulations.

              This is something that other clubs have also attempted to do by constructing a third party organisation where minors from Africa, South America or elsewhere are scouted and trained before they are able to legitimately and legally transfer and join the first team. However, the darker side of this is when clubs use these third party organisations to find a way of skirting around the regulations and this unfortunately encourages and facilitates the existence of fake agents and their problematic place within modern football. Atlético Madrid defended themselves by arguing that their conduct had not breached Spanish laws regarding protection of minors but CAS were quick to object and state that European and FIFA law takes precedence and that the club was in clear breach of the regulations. The consequence of this case was a two transfer window ban for Atlético Madrid handed to them by FIFA. This is not the only major punishment that has been handed to a club infringing upon such rules. A club in Italy was also given a two year transfer ban following the importation of 13 underage players from Nigeria between the years of 2013 and 2017.

              Perhaps then, the first step in preventing this practice is for the clubs to take a strong stance against the illegal international transfer of minors. One of the reasons why the issue is so embedded into football presently is that clubs inadvertently, and sometimes directly, encourage fake agents to bring players over. A greater understanding of how football creates an incentivising environment for both victims and perpetrators of player trafficking is needed to tackle the problem. For example, the youth talent that comes out of regions such as Africa and South America is indisputably exciting as shown in the graph below this paragraph; hence, many clubs seek to sign these talents as early as possible. The temptation for clubs is that fake agents could be necessary to find the gem coming out of these regions as the next Lionel Messi, Vincius Jr, Sadio Mane or Michael Essien. If clubs were to firmly oppose such immoral activity, there would be less of a market for fake agents and less minors would be exploited and torn away from their families and homelands.

              Some clubs and some countries have created several outreach sides that have formed in European cities and locations where a lot of these trafficked minors find themselves. This is part of the campaign to help support the players that are victims of the practice of football trafficking. It allows them to continue to play the sport they love and for a small minority of them, they may still be able to find the contract and opportunity that they originally came for. Often these sides will play pre-season friendlies or training matches against professional sides to give the players the chance to impress and help put their life and their career back on track.

              There also ought to be a strict licensing system to ensure that any agents, scouts or managers that do operate in these regions are trustworthy and legitimate. FIFA could implement a system for these agents to make licensing compulsory and associations such as the Confederation of African Football (CAF) and the South American equivalent, CONMEBOL, can publish the list of names of licensed agents operating in the regions. This means that families and players will be able to research the individual themselves and avoid working with illegitimate agents. Coupled with increased education and awareness campaigns for families and players to be aware of the risks and dangers that these individuals can pose, could lead to further reduction in the frequency of football trafficking. The key is to limit the gap in sporting opportunities, education, football systems and regulations in developing and developed countries to tackle the acceleration of the problem. For example, providing a safe and legal route for young talents from developing countries to play their football in other countries is important but transparency and regulated agent protocol will prevent this being undermined.

              Finally, families need to understand that they should not pay agents before a deal has been found. Education may help with this as uneducated families are currently succumbing to the temptation of the lucrative financial status of European football and will pay the agent to send their child there without being aware of the risks of it being a scam. Associations and organisations need to support families and youth players in protecting them from giving away significant sums of money to fake agents who are profiting from their illiteracy and circumstances.

    Summary

    The problem of human trafficking has become embedded in modern football; it is a football pandemic that has to be righted and steps must be taken to prevent it remaining a prevalent issue in the future of the beautiful game. It is a dirty secret of football currently and more needs to be done to heighten the awareness around the topic and to be able to address and tackle it. I hope that this blog is an eye opening insight into an issue that you may not have previously realised was plaguing football.

    NOTE: This blog has been released alongside my second novel, REMEMBER MY NAME, which aims to do exactly this; bring the issue of football trafficking into the spotlight. The novel follows the story of a minor in Africa that is trafficked to France in the exact manner I have described and looks into the shocking network and establishment of underworld football trafficking that exists in reality.

    If this blog has fueled your interest in this topic and you want to find out more, then this book is available to purchase here: https://geni.us/REMEMBER-MY-NAME

    Entwicklung der Spielerberater-Branche (I)

    0

    Einleitung

    Die Entwicklung des Spielerberaters von einer sozialen Norm ohne offiziellen Status zu einem begehrten Beruf, der für das Funktionieren der globalen Fußballmärkte von zentraler Bedeutung ist, lässt sich grob in vier Perioden aufteilen, die ebenfalls die kommerzielle Verbreitung des Sports widerspiegeln:

    • 1900-1960: Scouting und Vermittlung im Auftrag von Vereinen
    • 1960-1995: Vertretung von Fußballspielern
    • 1995-2015: Professionalisierung der Branche
    • seit 2015: Ära der Superagenten

    In diesem Beitrag betrachten wir die Anfänge der Spielerberater-Branche im 20. Jahrhundert von der Arbeit mit Vereinen bis hin zur Repräsentation von Spielern. Die weiteren zeitlichen Perioden werden in den folgenden Beiträgen näher beleuchtet.

    Scouting und Vermittlung im Auftrag von Vereinen

    Seit Beginn der Professionalisierung des Fußballsports existiert auch das Berufsbild des Vermittlers. Ursprünglich übernahmen diese Scouting- und Rekrutierungsaufgaben für Vereine. Jedoch fokussierten sich immer mehr Vereine auf die Scoutingarbeit und verringerten damit die Wichtigkeit von Vermittlern als Mittelsmännern durch die Entstehung von eigenen Scouting-Netzwerken.

    Anlass dafür war die Einführung eines sogenannten „Retain & Transfer“-System im Jahr 1893 in Großbritannien. Dieses System bot den Fußballvereinen die Möglichkeit, viel Kontrolle über Spielertransfers auszuüben. So übernahmen die meisten Vereine selbst Verantwortung für das Verpflichten und Verkaufen von Spielern und die Rolle der Vermittler war nicht mehr zentral für das Transfersystem.

    Der englische Fußballverband (FA) vertrat die Meinung, dass die Vermittler gegen die ethischen Grundsätze des Fußballs verstoßen. Dies führte letztendlich dazu, dass jegliche Aktivitäten von Einzelpersonen, die als Vermittler von Vereinen oder Spielern profitierten, offiziell verboten wurden. Obwohl Vereine ihre eigenen Scouting-Netzwerke bildeten und die Zusammenarbeit mit Vermittlern offiziell verboten war, bestand nach wie vor Nachfrage nach den Mittelsmännern.

    Das Image der Vermittler war zu diesem Zeitpunkt bereits umstritten. Ein wichtiger Faktor zugunsten der Vermittler war die zunehmende Liberalisierung des globalen Transfermarkts. Bereits sehr früh wurden Spieler aus aller Welt in verschiedene Länder transferiert. Voraussetzung dafür war, dass das Handeln der Vereine mit den jeweiligen inländischen Transfermarktbeschränkungen übereinstimmte. Der englische Fußballverband war zu diesem Zeitpunkt noch kein Mitglied der FIFA. Dementsprechend mussten ausländische Klubs keine Ablösesummen für Spieler aus Großbritannien zahlen. Vermittler aus dem In- und Ausland erkannten eine große Möglichkeit und schlossen sich zusammen, um Spieler aus England ins Ausland zu transferieren.

    Die weite Verbreitung von Vermittlern auf den wichtigsten Fußballmärkten begann am Ende des Zweiten Weltkriegs. Es war jedoch keine Arbeitsgesetzgebung zum Schutz von Arbeitnehmern vorhanden, sodass die Spieler nicht professionell beraten wurden. Vielmehr wurden sie wie Ware hin und her transferiert. Auf dem Transfermarkt gab es viele Absprachen zwischen Managern und Direktoren der Vereine. Spielertransfers wurden zu überhöhten Gebühren vereinbart, um Geld in ihrer Steuererklärung zu verbuchen. Die tatsächliche Gebühr des Transfergeschäfts wurde in den Konten des kaufenden Vereins als viel niedriger verbucht. Alle Parteien, die an dem Geschäft beteiligt waren, teilten dann das zusätzliche Geld auf. Nur ein kleiner Teil blieb für den Spieler übrig.

    Das damalige Transfersystem wurde als sklavenähnlich kritisiert. Seit den 1950er Jahren kam es in ganz Europa vermehrt zu Konflikten zwischen Spielern und Klubbesitzern. Hauptbestandteil waren Forderungen nach höheren Löhnen oder Wechselwünsche.

    Vertretung von Fußballspielern

    1960 wurde auch in England akzeptiert, dass die Einschränkungen auf dem Arbeitsmarkt nicht förderlich waren. Die Spielergewerkschaft PFA nutzte ihren Einfluss, um gegen den Höchstlohn und das „Retain & Transfer“-System zu kämpfen. Die Abschaffung des Höchstlohns im Jahr 1961 balancierte die Verhandlungsmacht zwischen Spielern und Vereinen aus. Die meisten Athleten begannen daher, ihre Verträge mit der Beratung und Hilfe persönlicher Vertreter auszuhandeln. In den folgenden drei Jahren stiegen die Löhne der Spieler in der höchsten Spielklasse um 61%.

    Im Jahr 1963 wurde die Liberalisierung des Arbeitsmarktes fortgeführt. In diesem Jahr entschied der High Court im Fall George Eastham, dass das „Retain & Transfer“-System illegal sei. Es beinhalte nicht zu rechtfertigende Handelsbeschränkungen. Durch diese Liberalisierung begannen die Spieler, das Machtungleichgewicht auszugleichen. Durch die Flexibilisierung des Spielertransfers ließen Ligen und Fußballverbände den Einsatz von Vermittlern offiziell zu. Es gab jedoch immer noch Einschränkungen für die Freiheit von Spielern: Vereine konnten die Registrierung von Spielern einseitig verlängern, solange Bedingungen angeboten wurden, die denen ihres vorherigen Vertrages entsprachen. Im Wesentlichen konnten sie einen Spieler so lange an den Verein binden, wie der Verein bereit war, für die Dienste des Spielers zu zahlen. Es war unabhängig davon, ob der Spieler überhaupt bei diesem Verein bleiben wollte.

    Ende der 1960er Jahre nahm das Medieninteresse am Sport als Teil des regulären Fernsehprogramms enorm zu und brachte enorme Einnahmen für die Ligen. In den späten 1970er Jahren schauten Vereine zunehmend auf den globalen Markt. Somit waren Spieler über ihre nationalen Verbände hinaus vermarktbar. Berater spielten daher zunehmend eine wichtige Rolle bei der Internationalisierung. Die unterschiedlichen Transferbestimmungen und Arbeitsmarktsysteme in verschiedenen Ländern führten zu Herausforderungen in der Informationssicherung. Für Vereine war es nach wie vor sehr schwierig, verlässliche Informationen über die Qualität von Spielern auf nationaler und internationaler Ebene zu erhalten. Auch wenn diese verfügbar waren, war die voraussichtliche zukünftige Leistung der Spieler äußerst schwierig einzuschätzen. Migrationsmuster innerhalb der Fußballindustrie waren hauptsächlich sozial eingebettet. Eine angemessene ökonomische Spielerbewertung war kaum möglich. So konnten Spielerberater ihre Position auf dem Transfermarkt stärken und etablierten Migrationskanäle. Diese wurden durch die Lockerung der Transferbeschränkungen für ausländische Spieler (bspw. England 1978 und Italien 1980) und das Entstehen neuer Märkte (bspw. Zerfall der Sowjetunion) begünstigt.

    Die zunehmende Internationalisierung und die damit verbundene Medienberichterstattung in Verbindung mit den Reformen der Transfermarktbestimmungen führten zu Lohnerhöhungen in der gesamten Welt des Fußballs.

    Haupteinnahmequelle der Ligen und Vereine sind seither die Einnahmen, die durch die Vermarktung von Übertragungsrechten erzielt werden. Hier sind die Einnahmen (in Millionen Pfund) der Premier League-Vereine in der Spielzeit 1991/1992 und den Saisons zwischen 2011/2012 und 2022/2023 gegenübergestellt.

    Der Wert der Spielerverträge nahm also zu. So wurde der Beruf des Fußballberaters lukrativer und eine neue Generation von Beratern entstand. Diese unterstützten Spieler hauptsächlich bei ihren Werbeverträgen oder berieten die Spieler in Rechtsfragen.

    Seit den 1980er Jahren sind Berater auf dem Transfermarkt alltäglich. Ohne offizielle Anerkennung durch einen Fußballverband war ihre Tätigkeit jedoch in keiner Weise reguliert. Es fehlte zusätzlich an jeglicher Überwachung bei Transferverhandlungen. Dies führte zu unangemessenen Verhaltensweisen von Beratern, Managern und Fußballdirektoren. In den frühen 1990er Jahren bestätigten einige Fußballmanager illegale Zahlungen an Beratern bei Spielertransfers.

    Die FIFA erkannte die Tätigkeit von Spielerberatern erst im Jahr 1994 offiziell an. Reglementiert wurde die Tätigkeit mit einem von allen Fußballverbänden akzeptierten Lizenzierungssystem. Diese formelle Anerkennung implizierte eine strengere Definition und Regelung der Rolle, Pflichten und Verantwortung der Berater. Die Lizenz wurde offiziell von dem jeweiligen nationalen Fußballverband ausgestellt.

    Zusammenfassung

    Die Tätigkeit des Spielerberaters war ursprünglich die Rolle des reinen Vermittlers. Diese Bezeichnung besteht bereits seit dem frühen 20. Jahrhundert im Fußball. Bis zur Einführung des „Transfer & Retain“-System standen Vermittler im Zentrum aller Transfers. Das Image der Berater ist seit jeher umstritten. Nach einem kurzeitigen Verbot für Vermittlungsarbeit wurde diese Rolle im globalen und liberalen Transfermarkt jedoch immer bedeutsamer. Gründe dafür sind die zunehmende Professionalisierung, Internationalisierung und Medialisierung.

    The Challenging Reality of Being a Football/Soccer Agent

    0

    Introduction

    On the surface it may seem as though being a football agent is a ‘dream job’ for anyone who loves the sport. Through various mediums such as popular culture, the media and even Hollywood through Jerry Maguire, the agency profession is portrayed as an extravagant and luxurious lifestyle. The press have played a significant role in publicising the flamboyant and flashy side of agents, particularly those that represent the very top clients. This has moulded the common public perception of agents and the work that we do that is usually very different to the reality.

    In this blog, we will offer an insider’s view into what being a football agent is really like. Beyond the idyllic impression that agents earn lucrative sums of money, mix with the rich and famous, manage world-class athletes and get to watch football all day long, there is far more to the job that isn’t quite as glamorous. This blog is aimed at informing and educating a wider audience about this crazy but brilliant industry we work in and highlight the importance of understanding the challenges we face and the vast volume of work that successful agents need to put in behind the scenes and beyond the glitz and glamour.

    The Financial Reality

    As in any industry and profession, money in football agency is hard earned. The majority of agents, particularly at the beginning of their career, will spend lots of time battling to find enough of an income to support their livelihood. In some cases, agents will work another job to supplement their income in the hope that one day they will be able to take on agency as a full time occupation. The press will only speak about the biggest agents that are involved in the biggest (and often most lucrative) deals, transfers and contracts. For the other 99% of agents, this is usually far removed from the job they are doing. The issue, of course, is that not every agent can represent top clients that earn tens or possibly even hundreds of thousands every week in the top leagues.

    Getting the first client and, thereafter, the first commission income is usually the first obstacle to be faced and can be the most challenging aspect of the job. Agents can spend years grafting and grinding, developing their network, their knowledge and their capabilities as an agent yet it can be to no short-term avail and they may not earn any money from the job during this period. This is a harsh truth for many who may have entered the industry under the common belief that there is an abundance of money to be made as a football agent.

    Even for an agent who is representing a client and earning good commission from them, it is impossible to become complacent and comfortable. An agent always has to be on their toes and proactive in the industry to ensure that they keep the situation that way. Clients can come and go, sometimes through no fault of the agent, and suddenly this source of income is lost. For agents that earn solely through commission, this can be incredibly difficult and they can feel an unbearable sense of pressure. If the agent is not with a larger agency that pays stable and set salaries, there is no secure and guaranteed income and losing a client can have a catastrophic impact upon an agent’s livelihood. Any profession where income is not guaranteed is a daunting one and it is a frightening part of football that agents, particularly independent ones, have to face and be prepared for.

    Sometimes other financial obstacles arise that an agent may be unprepared for. For example, I have previously dealt with a club that spoke directly with the player and his family before signing his first professional contract and said that he should not use an agent. The family took the advice and my part was removed from the deal and negotiation. However, as it turned out, the club brought in their own agent who was a close friend of the sporting director instead to help him financially benefit. Agents that work unethically with club officials can be an economic burden for agents that try to conduct their business professionally and morally.

    Relentless and Continual Competition

    Football as a whole can be an unforgiving and turbulent environment. This is most certainly the case for football agents too. Far from being a typical ‘9-5’ job, the reality is that an agent is ‘on the clock’ 24 hours a day, seven days a week. A client can and will need to contact their agent at any hour of the day with almost any request and they need to be available to help and assist. It is difficult to succeed as an agent if a client feels as though they are uncontactable; the role of the agent is to be there to support them whenever, wherever and however.

    The scope of the job is equally endless. The tasks that agents have to fulfil for clients and the challenges they may face whilst doing so are incredibly unpredictable and can be of almost any nature but will become a part of the job description and consequently, another tickbox in the criteria to fulfil to be a successful agent. In short, no two days will ever be the same. This can often be a considerable difficulty for an agent. The sheer extent of obligations to clients, the day-to-day turbulence and the immense unpredictability of the profession can be difficult to come to terms with and can be a daunting mental battle.

    It takes a certain character and person to willingly and successfully commit themselves to such a lifestyle. It requires a lot of sacrifices and a unique degree of passion and desire to work in the industry. Many things that can be taken for granted in other professions do not quite work the same in agency. For one, holidays without a phone or laptop and complete breaks from work are difficult to manage. Usually, a client will still need the agent during this time and there may be ongoing discussions and deals that cannot be completely avoided and delayed for a prolonged period. An agent must accept this reality and will hopefully have a supporting and understanding family around them to help balance the lifestyle. It can become incredibly draining and mentally taxing to feel as though you can never fully switch off from work. It is vital that agents find a way of switching on and off efficiently to protect themselves and look after relationships with family and friends whilst also being able to successfully operate as an agent.

    An important factor to note that further complicates things is that the profession is incredibly competitive in almost every aspect. Every part of the job involves some form of competition with other agents or other professionals in football. It is an industry where the volume of work and purposeful dedication an agent invests into it directly correlates with their career success in financial terms and beyond. The mental challenge that agents face is that for every hour they are not working or are not contactable, there may be plenty of other agents out there who are. From the process of signing a client to trying to get a deal over the line, agents are under constant pressure and in direct competition with colleagues. Other agents may want clients that are already signed or want to be part of a deal and a lapse in professionalism and focused dedication may mean an agent loses out on an opportunity. Some agents will try anything and everything to oust other agents and it can be an unpleasant, cutthroat environment to be a part of.

    What can make the level of sacrifice and dedication required even harder is the frequency of disloyalty that you may be shown as an agent. Unfortunately, in some cases you may have put in two or more years of devotion to the career of a player but they may decide to leave you if another agent offers them money for example. The unspoken truth is that the families of players can sell their child to other agents for their own financial gain. Agents should never offer players money in my opinion as those that come for money will leave for money and it creates a toxic relationship with unstable foundations.

    An extreme example of what the consequences of exchanging money may be was when I was asked by a father to pay a sum of €25,000 to continue representing the player. I was unsure what the money would have been for so spoke further with the wife who informed me the father was looking to fund his gambling addiction. Hence, I objected to sending any money. As a result, after five years of service to the player, the father changed his number and explained that they no longer wished to work with us anymore and we lost the client. This emphasises the reality that loyalty from players is very difficult to come by.

    Put simply, agents do not have it easy when it comes to the actual nature of the work, exaggerated by the fact that the industry is a brutal, unrelenting and unforgiving one. A point of consolation on this is that there is actually a small protection mechanism in place for agents. If a client does leave you but, for example, they have two years left on the contract you negotiated for them, you are still entitled to this commission. This prevents your work becoming completely futile.

    Problem Solving

    A lot of the work that good agents do is thankless. The job demands a vast array of  extensive and occasionally laborious tasks that an agent completes behind the scenes in order to best serve their clients. What the public sees for football agents may be the photos taken at transfer completions posing with the client and is often accompanied with details of large sums of money that will be exchanged and shared between parties. What isn’t as commonly portrayed and explained is the volume of work that the agent had to put in to get to that stage.

    Negotiations, discussions and addressing issues are usually processes that go on for a prolonged period and will occupy a considerable proportion of an agent’s time. It can be a stressful and demanding part of the job but is a necessary one to eventually reap the rewards. Sometimes, it can seem as though problems continually raise their heads and as the agent, you are simply moving from solving one problem to the next. A key role of the agent is problem solving and this is not a narrow field; remember a client or  anyone the agent is dealing with can raise any kind of issue that needs addressing at any time.

    Another part of problem solving for agents is made more difficult by the ever evolving landscape of football and the extensive and intricate regulations surrounding the work of agents. This adds another daily or at least weekly task onto an agent’s to-do list. Keeping up with regulations and the current market is absolutely imperative for a successful career as an agent and to avoid encountering ethical and legal issues. Clients may often make requests or enquiries that require research and knowledge that the agent needs to conduct and obtain. It is hardly an exhilarating requirement of the job but it is an unavoidable and necessary one.

    For the client, particularly if they are a young player you are an important mentor for their career and hence, you are also considered as their personal problem solver. Your role is to address challenges they may face and to motivate and to support them in overcoming it. This may be as simple as messaging before and after a game to encourage them or to console them after a bad performance, the burden is shared with you. There are a lot of problems that may arise such as injury or mental health struggles and this becomes a part of your service as the agent to ensure there is no long term detriment to the player’s career.

    The fundamental challenge that this section has outlined is that an agent need not only overcome their own problems and difficulties in their lives but that they also are required to solve the problems of others as part of the job. The best work of a good agent is predominantly done on the worst days for a client. When a client faces a bad day, week, month, transfer, contract situation, football issue, family concern or any other issue, it is the responsibility of the agent to act in a way to alleviates the problem from the player as much as possible. Taking on the additional burden of other people’s problems may not seem like a desirable task and it is the case for many that this part of the job can be overwhelming and unsustainable. However, the best agents are able to thrive under the responsibility of solving their clients’ problems. Once again, this is something that is rarely mentioned in popular culture and media when forming perceptions of football agents.

    Meeting Expectations

    I have already touched on a major expectation that agents face in this line of work; namely that of being available 24/7 to clients. However, it is not just the client that sets high expectations of an agent. Pressure and dependency can come from a variety of angles and an agent has the sometimes impossible task of keeping everyone happy as much as they can.

    There is an extensive list of parties that are invested in and involved with the work of the agent. Of course, the client is the top priority and everything an agent does is to best serve them, but there may also be a wider responsibility to others. For example, the family members of the client will be another watchful eye on the agent and the value they are adding to the relative’s career. An agent has to handle, develop and maintain a relationship with their family and hence, has to dedicate adequate time to this or they will risk losing the client.

    Then you have added pressure from another source; the clubs. This can often involve several relationships with individuals such as the Sporting Director, the coach, other players, scouts, the club doctor and more. The reputation of an agent, the way they operate and the manner in which they conduct their business is incredibly important here. However, reputation in football is as fragile as it is important. I always say that it can take years to build a good reputation and consequently, strong relationships with people in the industry, but it can take five minutes to tarnish it forever. This is arguably no truer than for football agency. Even the simplest of mistakes and errors can have a significant and lasting impact on an agent’s career success. The vulnerability and instability of these relationships, particularly with clubs and clients is an extraordinary pressure that comes as part of being an agent.

    For agents working under the umbrella of larger agencies, there will be additional expectations set of them. For example, an agency will have different targets that each agent is expected to reach depending upon their exact role within the company. This places a specific demand upon the agent that becomes another aspect of the expectations they must work hard to meet, reinforcing the reality that an agent’s career is fragile and perishable. It can sometimes feel as though demands and requests are coming from all angles and an agent can become consumed by this excessive responsibility for such an array of things. It can be enormously difficult to cope with everything, keep themselves organised and stay on top of anything that comes their way. Yet for the parties, this is irrelevant. They set these tasks to the agent as it is a part of the job and their expectation will be that the agent will complete whatever it is they need. This can be a difficult challenge.

    A final point to note on the level of expectation that can be placed on you as the agent is from the partners of players. The reality is that wives and girlfriends, for example, are a significant factor in a player’s life and career. They can create issues if they feel an agent is “uncontrollable” to them and is not meeting their expectations. It is not uncommon for partners to meddle and to try to remove you to bring in an agent that they can dictate to to benefit them. Often their expectations can be difficult to manage and meet and it is somethings agents have to take into consideration an handle carefully.

    Summary

    The work of an agent is exciting, unique and can be very rewarding in many ways. It is a privilege to be able to work in the beautiful game and alongside the athletes that make the sport of football, or soccer, what it is. However, the falsehood of the lifestyle of an agent that has been, and continues to be, fabricated by mainstream popular media can give a dangerous impression of what it is really like to work as a football agent. Our hope is that this blog highlights the important, and often unseen, parts of the profession that can be incredibly challenging and difficult. It should have shown that to succeed as an agent requires extraordinary dedication, unrelenting motivation and a particular type of person. By educating people on the work of agents, hopefully a more realistic perception of the industry will become commonplace and a greater appreciation for the role we play and the value we add to football.

    Being a Football/Soccer Agent at the FIFA World Cup

    0

    Introduction

    As everyone knows, the FIFA World Cup is currently taking place in Qatar. As the first version of the global competition to be staged in the Northern Hemisphere’s winter, it is one that has been well discussed ever since Qatar was announced as the host nation of the 2022 World Cup over a decade ago at the end of 2010.

    This blog refrains from being another article that highlights the much-spoken about topics that you are likely to have read and heard. Instead, this blog aims to immerse the reader into a new perspective of the most watched tournament on the planet; through the lens of football agents. We will explain the different components of the roles and responsibilities that come with representing a client at the World Cup and the uniqueness of the opportunity it presents in a variety of areas.

    Supporting your Player

    Firstly it is important to acknowledge the privilege of representing a client at the World Cup. As well as it being a remarkable achievement for them as a player, it similarly gives an immense sense of satisfaction to the agent. All of your hard work and the services that you have provided to the player have helped them on their journey to representing their country at the very peak of the game. If and when you are fortunate enough as an agent to have a client play in the World Cup, it becomes an extended part of your job description to offer your services to benefit their tournament experience, performance and ensure that their presence on the global stage has a long-term positive impact.

    The World Cup is a completely different atmosphere, environment and setting both on and off the pitch, particularly in a country like Qatar. It can be overwhelming for players, especially if it is their first time and as the agent, you ought to assist as far as possible to relieve them of unnecessary stresses and worries that could be detrimental to their performance on the pitch. As is the case with most of your value as an agent, you want to create a situation where the client only has to focus on performing optimally on the pitch as the agent takes care of everything else.

    Unfortunately at the World Cup, there are several elements that may create worries for your player that are unavoidable. Firstly, the intense pressure and scrutiny of playing for their country at a tournament watched by billions of people and with the eyes of their country following every tackle, every pass, every shot and every detail of their performance is an obvious consideration. Every player reacts differently to such a situation, some relish the pressure and thrive in competitions like this whilst others can really struggle mentally and physically and can be cripplingly affected by normal human emotions such as nerves, anxiety and stress.

    Understand and Protecting their Mentality

    The agent needs to understand their clients mentality and the relationship you have with your client can help you gauge how they are feeling. For a client that is mentally vulnerable and has concerns at the World Cup, the agent can intervene and call upon the professional advice of psychologists and mental coaches to ensure they get the support they need. For a player who may have worked their entire life and career to reach the moment where they are selected to represent their nation at a World Cup, it would be an incredible shame if the sense of occasion and anxiety is overwhelming and they fail to do their ability justice and are incapable of enjoying the experience. It is a rare opportunity that few individuals will ever achieve and is meant to be enjoyed and remembered as some of, if not the greatest, moments in a player’s career.

    The agent also needs to make their client aware of the dangers of social media and reading press reports and articles during the tournament and in football in general. The pressure is enough for a player without reading negative comments and scrutiny from the public and the pundits. In many cases, the best advice is to avoid engaging with these things during the competition for the sake of protecting the mental health and confidence of the player. In extreme cases, the agent may even be able to use their trusted contacts in the media industry to stand up for the player and create more positive media coverage of the client and then these can be deliberately shown to the player if needed to give them encouragement. The agent lives through the highs and lows of the campaign with their client and you can feel the pain of negative press and poor performances so this makes it all the more important to defend and support the client throughout in the best way possible.

    On the topic of the media, part of the unavoidable World Cup experience is extensive duties for the top players. If a client falls into this category it is another additional burden that they have to deal with but the agent is able to support them. Preparation in many areas of football is key and arguably none more so than when under the spotlight of journalists in a World Cup press conference. For all things football, the player will usually be used to answering the common questions surrounding their own and their teammates’ performances and maybe even the performances of the other countries. However, what has been particularly highlighted by the Qatar World Cup is that in the modern era of football, media duties and interview topics can go far beyond just football.

    It is important to remember as the agent that the client is most likely a young adult who has grown up playing the sport they love and are now fortunate enough to do it as a career. Whilst they will of course be aware or be made aware of certain topics, they are often unlikely to have in-depth knowledge and understanding of issues beyond football that may be addressed with players in press conferences. As the agent, this should be seen as a great opportunity to show the value you can add to your client. You can do the research for them and help them feel comfortable that if they are asked about certain sensitive or complex topics, they will be able to answer them.

    Usually, the player is likely to have access to a psychologist or mental coach through their club but this remains a vital source of support during the World Cup as well. On top of ensuring the player has this available to them, the agent also needs to go to great lengths themselves to be a pillar of mental support.

    For example, during the Brazilian World Cup in 2014 I spent the month alongside Mesut Özil as a reliable advocate of his in the face of any challenge and pressure that came to him during the tournament. I took it upon myself to speak with him before and after every game, offering words of encouragement and positivity as well as trying to keep his mind in the right place to perform at his optimum for his country on the biggest stage.

    Capitalising on Unique Opportunities for your Client

    The previous section may have made it seem as though a lot of the agent’s involvement with a client throughout a World Cup is on the negative side and the hardships that come as part of the package. And certainly, the more negative aspects you alleviate from the player and the more you take on yourself, the better your service to the player. However, there is also a vast array of unique positive opportunities specific to the World Cup stage that may be presented to your player. Although the statistics for the 2022 edition are obviously not available yet but the graph below shows the true status of the tournament as a globally watched event:

    As mentioned, billions of people watch the World Cup and hence, this creates an exciting and lucrative platform for opportunistic sponsors and global brands and consequently, for your client. For any player that performs on such a stage, it is inevitable that these sponsors will have an element of interest in collaborating with them. If a client is a top player they will already have endorsements in place as a result of your services to them in finding sponsorship deals and the World Cup is simply a new accentuated platform to capitalise upon the partnership and promotion.

    An agent can consider this well before the competition takes place. For example, in the knowledge that a client will likely be chosen as part of their country’s World Cup squad, the agent ought to negotiate with their sponsors to include clauses in the commercial contract that stipulate bonuses and extra remuneration if the player appears on the global stage. For example, a 20% bonus for every World Cup appearance would be an appropriate reflection of the additional promotion of the products, particularly for boot deals.

    Even if these clauses are not in place, there will still be additional opportunities. It is the role of the agent to proactively find unique possibilities that could only arise from a client participating in the World Cup. Clothing brands, headphones, travel attire and transport companies may all be potential collaborations that you can find for your client. These can often be more lucrative and beneficial for your client’s profile than regular deals due to the magnitude of the tournament. The extreme finances and sponsorships that World Cup’s attract is shown in the graph below:

    Having said this, the performance of the client on the pitch is of utmost importance and should always be emphasised as the greatest priority. The agent’s understanding of the player is crucial here as they need to be aware of the client’s willingness to engage with commercial obligations without sacrificing the level of football they can produce on the pitch. Some may want to solely focus on football but others will be more than happy to take on off-pitch commitments to build their personal brand and raise their global profile. Ultimately, it is the player’s choice as to whether they are interested in off-pitch opportunities based upon the guidance of the agent. Bringing the opportunities and contracts to the client is the agent’s job, signing it is the decision of the player and should not be forced.

    Financially rewarding projects at the World Cup are not the only method of boosting the positive publicity and profile of a client that an agent should be aware of. Revisiting the point made at the end of the first section, this global platform and intense media coverage also provides an opportunity for clients to voice opinions on what they’re most passionate about. This can be a sensitive area but if delivered in the correct manner, of which the agent is tasked with advising upon, the client can give powerful messages of support and solidarity with people suffering from issues around the world. Taking a stance on human rights, particularly on the world stage can highlight the most important concerns of your client and raise awareness of solutions. However, this can often leave clients open to criticism, particularly if their performances fall below expectations. As the agent it is once again part of the job criteria to be able to sensibly advise and support clients in such situations.

    A Unique Networking Opportunity

    A final point to raise when understanding the implications of being an agent at a football World Cup is the unprecedented variety of possible contacts and new relationships with professionals in an extensive list of industries that can benefit your own career.

    Of course, for the player, they are given a global platform to express themselves and perform on the pitch and to impress scouts and clubs from around the world. However, for the agent it is also an extremely important opportunity for you to impress on a different stage and connect with the wider football world.

    Remember, at the biggest competition in the world, there are influential and well connected people in attendance from almost any industry. It is a chance to begin relationships with club and national association officials, representatives from brands and sponsors, the media and journalists, the family members of players and their agents and with other players from every corner of the football globe.

    The importance of capitalising on the opportunity cannot be stressed enough as it can help improve the services you are able to provide to your client(s) and facilitates operating in additional markets in the future which can only be a positive consequence.

    Summary

    To summarise, the World Cup is a magnificent tournament, fully deserving of its title as the largest sporting event on the planet. For players, it is often the peak of their career and something they have dreamed of since they first kicked a football. For the agent, as this blog has shown, it presents an enthralling opportunity to develop your own capabilities in the profession and demonstrate the extent of value you can bring to your client in various facets from media advice, mental support and commercial deals.

    I am in the very fortunate position that one of my clients has been through the World Cup journey and held the famous trophy at the end. For me as the agent, this is one of my proudest moments and I would like to think I played a small part at least in his successful contributions during the victorious campaign. It is a remarkable and extraordinary experience to have a client at the World Cup and similarly to the players themselves, it is important to savour every memorable moment and of course, to work incredibly hard to best serve the interests and performance of your play on and off the pitch.

    Spielerberater und Spielervermittler

    0
    Einleitung

    Im modernen Fußball spielen die Begriffe Spielerberater oder Spielervermittler eine zentrale Rolle. Um die Arbeit jener besser verstehen zu können, dient dieser Beitrag dazu, die Begrifflichkeiten zu definieren. Im heutigen Sprachgebrauch werden die Begriffe „Berater“ und „Vermittler“ als Synonyme verwendet. Ursprünglich müssen sie jedoch differenziert betrachtet werden.

    Spielervermittler

    Ein Spielervermittler ist laut der Fédération Internationale de Football Association (FIFA) „eine natürliche Person, die gegen Entgelt Spieler bei einem Verein vorstellt, um Arbeitsverträge auszuhandeln oder neu zu verhandeln, oder die im Hinblick auf den Abschluss eines Transfervertrags zwei Vereine einander vorstellt […]“.

    Durch den Spielervermittlungsvertrag erhält der Spielervermittler den Auftrag, gegen eine Vergütung dem Spieler durch die Suche und Auswahl von geeigneten Vertragspartnern einen Arbeitsplatz zu vermitteln. Der Auftrag des Spielervermittlers – für den Fall, dass er für diesen und nicht für den Verein tätig ist – besteht also darin, für den Spieler mögliche Vertragspartner zu suchen. Ziel ist es, den Abschluss eines Arbeitsvertrags zu erreichen.

    Ein Spielervermittler kann unter Umständen sogar damit beauftragt werden, den Arbeitsvertrag selbstständig auszuhandeln. Der Spieler muss in einem solchen Fall letztlich nur noch unterschreiben. Für den Spielevermittler besteht sogar die Möglichkeit, namens und im Auftrag des Spielers den Vertrag für diesen zu unterzeichnen. Eine solche Vereinbarung inklusive einer entsprechenden Vollmacht zwischen Spieler und Spielervermittler geht über die eigentliche Vermittlungstätigkeit weit hinaus. Eine derart weitgehende Ermächtigung des Spielervermittlers ist dementsprechend eher selten der Fall.

    Die Pflicht des Spielers ist höchstens, den Spielervermittler im Falle des Erfolgs finanziell zu vergüten. Im deutschen Profifußball wird die Vergütung jedoch üblicherweise von dem aufnehmenden Verein übernommen.

    In Deutschlands höchster Spielklasse, der 1. Bundesliga, wurden laut der Deutschen Fußball-Liga (DFL) im Geschäftsjahr 2021 insgesamt mehr als 171 Millionen Euro an Spieleberater ausgezahlt. Borussia Dortmund zahlt mit Abstand am meisten an Spielerberater (32.781.000 Euro), gefolgt von RB Leipzig (25.853.000 Euro) und FC Bayern München (25.813.000 Euro).

    Daher geht der Spieler bei einem Vermittlungsvertrag keinerlei finanzieller Verpflichtungen ein. Oftmals wird jedoch vereinbart, dass der Spieler dem Spielervermittler Unterlagen zu Verfügung stellen muss. Dies kann unter anderem seinen bisherigen Arbeitsvertrag oder einen medizinischen Bericht über seinen Gesundheitszustand beinhalten.

    Ein Spielervermittler kann nicht nur von einem Spieler, sondern auch von einem Verein beauftragt werden. Ziel ist es dabei immer, den Kontakt zwischen Spieler und Verein herzustellen. Diese Tätigkeit kann mit der eines Maklers verglichen werden, der die Möglichkeit eines Vertragsschlusses nachweist, hier in Form eines Arbeitsverhältnisses.

    Der Spielervermittlungsvertrag ähnelt auch deshalb einem Maklervertrag, weil der Spielervermittler nur bei Erfolg zu bezahlen ist. In diesem Fall ist tritt der Erfolg dann ein, wenn ein Arbeitsvertrag abgeschlossen wird.

    Spielerberater

    Der Fußballspieler verkörpert ein Grundverständnis des Sports und der Leistung. Ein Sportler ist ein Wettkämpfer (lateinisch und altgriechisch). Das Bild des modernen Athleten jedoch wandelt sich vom reinen Wettkämpfer in Richtung des Spielers als Marke. Ein Fußballspieler im modernen Ökosystem ist nicht nur der Sportler, der eine Höchstleistung erbringt. Vielmehr bildet er eine komplexe Zusammenstellung aus dem Leistungsanspruch, der Bekanntheit in der Bevölkerung und der Wirtschaftskraft.

    Durch die zunehmende Kommerzialisierung des Fußballs ist jeder Spieler ein Baustein des sportlichen Wirtschaftsfaktors. Damit einhergehend ist er auch mit Herausforderungen konfrontiert, die mit dem eigentlichen Leistungssport nur indirekt verbunden sind. Dennoch ist es das Ziel, nach wie vor sportliche Höchstleistungen zu erbringen. Daher sind professionelle Fußballspieler zunehmend darauf angewiesen, einen Berater für all die Themen zu haben, denen sie sich selbst nicht widmen können oder wollen.

    Der Begriff „Berater“ wird als weit verbreitetes Synonym für Ratgeber benutzt und umfasst daher alle Experten auf einem bestimmten Fachgebiet in allen Bereichen, vor allem jedoch in der Wirtschaft und in den Rechtswissenschaften. Im Fußball-Kontext ist ein Spielerberater also ein Ratgeber von einem oder mehreren professionellen Fußballspielern, Amateurspielern oder Jugendspielern. Die Kernaufgabe eines Spielerberaters ist ebenfalls das Führen von erfolgreichen Vertragsverhandlungen im Sinne des Klienten mit einem Verein. Ein Berater deckt jedoch deutlich mehr Aufgabenfelder als die reine Vermittlung ab. Dabei spricht man unter anderem von folgenden Dienstleistungen:

    • Karriereplanung und Planung der Zeit nach der aktiven Karriere
    • Abschließen von Sponsoringverträgen
    • Public Relations und Markenaufbau
    • Sportliche Beratung und Analyse
    • Medizinische Beratung
    • Vermögensberatung und Business Ventures
    • Versicherungsberatung
    • Rechtsberatung
    • Wohltätigkeitsarbeit
    Zusammenfassung

    Berater sind durch ein gesetzliches Mandat gesetzlich befugt sind, im Namen mindestens einer der beiden Parteien zu handeln, die einen bestimmten Vertrag abschließen. Vermittler führen hauptsächlich nur materielle Handlungen durch (Abschluss von Verträgen, Vereinbarung von Treffen usw.), um die Vertragsparteien zusammenzuführen. Während Berater sich in ihrem Beruf hauptsächlich auf die Vertretung und Interessen des Athleten konzentrieren, fokussieren sich Vermittler hauptsächlich auf alle Arten von Transaktionen, an denen Spieler, Vereine und Unternehmen beteiligt sind.

    The Details and Intricacies of a Representation Contract for Football/Soccer Agents

    0

    Introduction

    Last week, we journeyed through the process of finding and selecting the right agent for a youth player. We briefly touched upon the final stage of signing with an agent; the representation contract. However, this is a complex and important element in its own right and hence, this week’s blog is dedicated to helping you understand everything involved with representation contracts.

    We will begin by outlining what exactly a representation contract is, before identifying the key clauses that should be considered when assessing a representation contract. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, we will address common issues that arise with representation contracts and how to avoid problematic commitments to agents.

    The Representation Contract

    Once a decision has been made as to which agent a player would like to sign with, the representation contract will be signed by both the player and the agent. The purpose of this contract is to create a legal and enforceable agreement between the parties. A contractual agreement of this manner stipulates different clauses for both engaging parties to act in adherence with and hence it is important to ensure it is favourable and agreeable for the player.

    The representation contract offers an element of legal safety and security for each party. If the contract contains all relevant information and requirements, it prevents either party acting wrongly within the relationship. Breaching such a contract can lead to termination with just cause and hence, protects the player if the agent does not behave in a professional manner as the player can then exit the relationship. Alternatively, it provides an element of protection for the agent contained within the exclusivity clause and prevents the player dealing with other agents.

    In most national football associations, there will be a template layout of a representation contract. However, agents and agencies are able to adapt the clauses and include any additional obligations specific to the work that they do. Nonetheless, the majority of a representation contract is universal and replicated in each country.

    In the following section I will outline the most important considerations that should be made regarding individual clauses. For now, it is important to know that in the Agent Regulations, FIFA have published a required list of clauses that must be included within the representation contract. These must be incorporated into every version of a representation contract in any FIFA member association. However, national associations can then also include further clauses. Importantly, FIFA stipulates that the Representation Contract must detail and specify the legal relationship between the player and the agent. Therefore, the minimum clauses to be included must refer to:

    1. The names of the parties: Make sure these are spelt right!
    2. The scope of services provided: think about what the duties of the agent are, what services does the player need them to help with.
    3. The duration of the legal relationship: covered further below.
    4. The remuneration due to the intermediary: the level of commission owed to the agent.
    5. The general terms of payment: how the agent will be paid.
    6. The date of conclusion: it must be clear the exact date on which the representation contract ends.
    7. The termination provisions: how can the contract end and if it is premature, what reasons would constitute a just cause.
    8. The signature of the parties: remember that if the player is a minor, their legal guardians also need to sign the contract.

    Important Clauses to Consider

    There can be a variety of clauses within the representation contract that are part of the minimum to be included set by FIFA or additional clauses included legally under the National Association. Each one needs to be read and understood fully. In this section, we will highlight a handful of specific clauses that are the most prominent factors of a representation contract. They are the clauses that stipulate the financial commitments of the agreement and also the clauses that outline the obligations that the player is under whilst in the period of the contract. As the next section will develop upon, the player must ensure that they are not entering into an unreasonable, unfair or problematic contract. The following are the kind of clauses that may lead to this undesirable outcome and need to be properly assessed.

    1. Duration: In some national associations such as the UK, the representation contract can only be for a maximum of two years before requiring renewal. However, in some countries this is not the case and in some circumstances, two years may still cause issues if the player is unable to terminate a contract if it has been breached by the agent
    2. Termination: The player needs to be satisfied that there are exit clauses within the contract that allows them to leave the agent without penalty if certain situations arise, or breaches of contract occur or even when it comes to deciding against renewing with their current agent and changing to another. There must not be a clause that requires the player to pay an agent when leaving them or a similarly detrimental obligation.
    3. Exclusivity: This is a very important part of a representation contract for a player to be aware of. It will state that the agent must be solely and exclusively responsible for representation of the player in any agency activity. However, it is important that the contract allows for the agents to obtain mandates if there is an opportunity in another territory that another person is better suited to represent the player for. Significantly, some countries such as Germany, have banned exclusivity of representation for agents. This is a risky situation for the agents but means that the players are not restricted or bound to sole representation. It is important to note that agents based in Germany have found ways around this by registering their companies in different FIFA countries. This trend means that they can bind the player to exclusivity.
    4. Remuneration & Commission: An obviously integral clause to consider and make sure is favourable to each party is the commission owed. This will often be written with a percentage of a player’s gross or net salary that will be owed to the agent for their services. The player must be certain that if they are obliged to pay a certain percentage of their salary to the agent, they must be fully trusting that they are paying a fair rate for the benefits and value of the services that the agent is providing. This is generally often around 10% of a player’s gross salary but may be slightly lower in leagues where the finances for players are higher such as the Premier League in the UK. Other factors such as whether the player pays the commission themselves or if it is the responsibility of the club as well as tax implications are all a part of this. There is a rule from FIFA that permits clubs to play the agent on the player’s behalf which is the norm. Importantly, the contract is still between the player and the agent and therefore, if the club does not pay, it is fundamentally the player who is liable to remunerate the agent according to the representation contract.
    5. Image Rights: Image rights and commercial commission will often be implemented into the representation contract and this once again needs to be assessed and agreed to in full knowledge of what it entails. Commercial commission is often a higher percentage (usually around 20%) than for playing contracts and once again, the player needs to understand how much money they are liable to pay the agent in commercial deals. In some countries, agents are finding a way to sign younger players below the legal age for a representation contract by instead signing an ‘image rights contract’ with them. Brands such as Nike and Adidas pick up players below the U16 level and agents are capitalising upon this. This image rights contract acts as an entry into a relationship with the player which will then transition into a representation agreement once the age is right. This is becoming more common in countries such as the UK.
    6. Territories: The representation contract will detail the extent of the jurisdiction for each agent. For example, in most cases the contract will specifically and expressly state that they represent you globally to ensure their exclusivity of your representation cannot be undermined, if exclusivity is permitted.

    Avoiding Problems

    If the representation contract is not carefully considered then there may be problematic consequences that affect the player’s career and beyond. It is clear from the previous sections that representation contracts are complex and intricate documents that form the basis of the agreement between the player and the agent. Hence, the meaning and understanding of each clause must be ascertained. It is essential that the contract is not signed without fully understanding the ‘terms and conditions’.

    Seeking the guidance and assistance of a lawyer is strongly recommended. Their legal knowledge and expertise will be helpful throughout the signing process and prevent the player entering into a contract that is difficult to leave and is disadvantageous to them financially or otherwise. Hopefully, this issue may never arise as if the player and the family have gone through the right process of selecting an agent and carried out appropriate due diligence as we explored last week, the trusted agent is unlikely to create such problems. However, it is a possibility and therefore, the importance of understanding and thoroughly considering the representation contract cannot be underestimated.

    A final suggestion I would make is that the representation contracts will never automatically renew. It is up to the player and the agent to come to a new agreement after the contract expires and to sign a renewed representation contract. However, I believe that as the contract expires, particularly if it is the end of the very first with that particular agent, the player and their family should ‘re-interview’ and reconsider the agent and other agents. By reevaluating the current agent it is possible to see if they are delivering upon the expectations they had set and adding the value the player had hoped for. Being open minded rather than fixed upon resigning with the same agent can enable finding the best opportunities for the player moving forward.

    Summary

    Following the stages outlined in last week’s blog, you will eventually reach the point at which a representation contract will be signed. After filtering through every potential option, the worst thing that can happen is to rush into a representation contract that creates one or more unforeseen disadvantages to the player. This blog has hopefully provided a useful insight into the structure and general contents of such a contract as well as pointing out some possible supplementary clauses that may be included. The player and their guardians must carefully review and understand the contract before signing and in most cases, a lawyer should be consulted for extra security as their expertise will ensure no detrimental obligations or requirements are contained within the contract.

    Que Significa ser un Agente de Fútbol: El trabajo que hacemos, las habilidades necesarias y lo que ha cambiado

    0

    Desde el inicio de la representación deportiva en el mundo del fútbol, los roles necesarios, responsabilidades, y demandas han cambiado de una gran manera. Los agentes de fútbol ya no son simples agentes que negocian el contrato laboral y transferencias de sus clientes, la responsabilidad es mucho mayor, por ende, se debería exigir mayor preparación para poder deliberar un gran servicio durante la corta carrera de los futbolistas.

    En este blog, primero discutiré en mayor detalle las diferencias del trabajo de los agentes tradicionalmente y lo que demanda ser un agente hoy en día. Seguidamente, describiré la cantidad de responsabilidades que implican ser un agente moderno.

    Agente Tradicional Versus Agente Moderno

    Para empezar, definiremos que es un agente, la Real Academia Española define a un agente como “persona que obra con poder de otra para gestionar algo en su nombre.” Tradicionalmente, el agente actúa como representante legal de su cliente en las negociaciones de extensiones de contratos entre el club y el jugador, las transferencias y exploran oportunidades potenciales. La gran diferencia con el agente moderno es la cantidad de oportunidades las cuales deben considerar para conseguir mejores opciones laborales para sus clientes, aparte de tratar solo con la parte contractual con el club.

    El rol que desempeña un agente se ha vuelto global. Un agente tiene la habilidad y responsabilidad de actuar como representante legal, y de hacerlo de manera leal, sincera y transparente en el mayor interés de su jugador. Sin embargo, el trabajo va más allá y exige mucha demanda por parte del agente, es un trabajo de tiempo completo.

    Hoy en día, las grandes agencias de representación están uniéndose, mientras que en el pasado los agentes solían operar de manera independiente. Ahora existen agencias de tamaño medio, como Family & Football que opera en más de 6 países; y de tamaño grande, que cuentan con más de 50 agentes trabajando juntos, con abogados internos, departamento de mercadeo, entre otras cosas, y oficinas en diferentes países. En el pasado, los agentes solían operar en un solo país, usualmente en el de origen, pero ahora es un trabajo global, todo está más conectado entre sí. 

    La FIFA reconoció por primera vez la profesión de los agentes en 1991 y los comenzó a regular. Previamente, los agentes lo hacían más como consultores. Luego, en 1995, después del caso Bosman, los agentes se volvieron más poderosos. Esto es debido al “free agent” o agente libre como estatus de jugador. El dinero creció en el negocio ya que se volvió global con la libre circulación de jugadores a través de ligas y países. Hoy en día, están volviendo más regulaciones por parte de la FIFA.

    En la siguiente gráfica, se muestra un reporte hecho por la FIFA en los últimos diez años de traspasos internacionales.

    El agente moderno debe tener conocimiento no solo de temas contractuales sino financieros, legales, de inversión a corto y largo plazo, oportunidades comerciales, redes sociales, mercadeo y branding, conocimiento de idiomas, entre otras, además de un entendimiento avanzado del fútbol. Hoy en día, el agente es responsable de encontrar oportunidades para su jugador no solo dentro de la cancha sino también fuera de ella.

    La Era de la Comercialización y las Redes Sociales

    Las redes sociales ciertamente han cambiado la manera en la que interactuamos unos con otros, la manera en que vivimos y la manera en la que se hacen/nacen los negocios. Las personas ya tienen el poder de tener una voz ante el mundo con ‘total’ libertad de expresión y apoyar las causas con las cuales cada individuo se identifica. Los atletas, en especial los jugadores de fútbol profesional, por ser el deporte más conocido mundialmente, tienen el poder de mover, motivar y tener millones de seguidores alrededor del mundo. Esto es muy interesante e importante comercialmente para las marcas y todas las empresas.

    Dentro de las habilidades necesarias del agente moderno están, encontrar oportunidades comerciales a sus jugadores usando la imagen y el poder de sus redes sociales. El hecho de tener una gran presencia digital significa nuevos contratos, nuevas oportunidades de negocio e incluso un mayor ingreso con el club actual. Por estas razones los agentes necesitan desarrollar la presencia digital de sus jugadores, tener conocimiento y entendimiento sobre las redes sociales, mercadeo, legal sobre derechos de imagen y branding para poder aprovechar las oportunidades que resulten.

    La globalización del fútbol es un fenómeno que aporta mucho al crecimiento de los jugadores como personalidades ante el ojo público. Esto requiere y exige a los agentes a desarrollar diferentes habilidades para poder conseguir buenas oportunidades para su cliente.  A medida que la popularidad, la riqueza financiera y el valor comercial del fútbol va creciendo en todo el mundo, más corporaciones y empresas lideres en la industria están dispuestas a invertir sumas sustanciales de dinero en el deporte. Este fenómeno comenzó con importantes acuerdos de patrocinio para patrocinadores de camisetas, derechos de denominación de estadios y trasmisiones televisivas. El alcance de patrocinios ahora se ha extendido a casi todos los elementos del sistema de fútbol, como materiales de entrenamientos, ofertas de botines, en Colombia guayos, programas de partidos y publicidad en estadios, y vincula el fútbol con las marcas de ropa, las aerolíneas, casas de apuestas y bebidas alcohólicas. Estos acuerdos de patrocinio pueden beneficiar a los jugadores y es la responsabilidad del agente moderno identificar con cuales conviene interactuar.

    Ejemplo en la siguiente imagen del delantero de la selección Colombia, Radamel Falcao en referencia a ganancias basadas en marcas patrocinadoras en años anteriores.

    Para ser un agente exitoso es importante entender la persona con la que se está trabajando, conocer la personalidad, las motivaciones, y aspiraciones que hay detrás del individuo complementada con el atleta de alto rendimiento. Es de gran importancia para el agente tener ese conocimiento para así poder desarrollar la marca personal del atleta en base a los rasgos reales de la persona y no una personalidad falsa. Esto es para presentar a la persona ante el ojo público y encontrar las oportunidades de patrocinios apropiadas y nuevos flujos de ingresos. Está marca personal se complementa y potencializa con la presencia digital.

    Responsabilidades del Agente Moderno

    Hoy en día, los agentes siguen cumpliendo los deberes fundamentales de la profesión adicionando las nuevas responsabilidades. Se encargan de la negociación de contratos laborales con el club, re-negociación o extensión de contratos, transferencias, identificación de oportunidades comerciales con marcas, manejar las relaciones publicas de su cliente, desarrollar las redes sociales, la marca personal, explorar nuevas oportunidades de negocio, asesoría financiera, apoyo en educación, en especial si son jugadores juveniles, ayuda en los planes post carrera deportiva, apoyar a la comunidad haciendo trabajo de caridad, apoyo a la familia, ser un mentor, encontrar apoyo de coach personal y mental, ser motivador, necesidades y seguimiento diario al desarrollo del jugador, entre otras funciones.   

    La función principal del agente es asegurarse de que su jugador sea valorado de la manera correcta por parte de los clubes. Tradicionalmente, el club comprador basaría el fichaje de un jugador en la capacidad para desempeñarse en el campo de fútbol. En la era moderna, ya no es el caso. Los jugadores tienen su propio valor comercial que pueden llevar a un club, lo cual crea oportunidades que el agente debe entender para garantizar que se llegue a un acuerdo justo. Un jugador que tenga una gran base de fanáticos e influencia global puede atraer grandes patrocinadores y diferentes fuentes de ingreso para el club a través de ventas de camisetas, entre otras. Esto es porque los fanáticos ya no son tan fans del club, hoy en día, siguen más a los jugadores que al mismo club, lo cual en algunas ocasiones puede resultar en el jugador teniendo poder de toma de decisiones dentro del mismo club. El conocimiento sobre los derechos de imagen y el valor comercial, así como la aptitud financiera general, es imprescindible para que un agente logre un resultado deseable para su cliente en estas situaciones.

    Tipos De Agentes

    La mayoría de las transferencias incluyen a varios agentes. En tiempos recientes se ha vuelto más común que los clubes compradores y/o vendedores simplifiquen el proceso usando el mismo agente en un acuerdo de representación múltiple. Sin embargo, las nuevas regulaciones por parte de la FIFA buscan prohibir esto. Cabe mencionar que la nueva legislación impide la representación múltiple en todas las circunstancias, excepto para actuar en nombre del jugador y el club comprador. Cualquier otro conflicto de intereses no será posible y alterara la forma en que los agentes operan dentro de los acuerdos.

    Una de las maneras en la que las responsabilidades de los agentes han cambiado es que hoy en día hay una mayor tendencia a que los operativos asuman el papel de representar a los clubes involucrados en un acuerdo. Han creado una versión alternativa de la profesión a la que se puede denominar como ‘agentes de club.’ La esencia del trabajo bajo este modelo sigue siendo la misma, actuar en el mejor interés del cliente, pero con el fin de lograr el resultado más deseable para el club comprador o vendedor.

    Figura en referencia al pago de comisiones para agentes de clubes.

    Los mandatos se han convertido en una norma dentro de la agencia del fútbol. Los clubes identifican jugadores de interés y otorgan mandatos a los agentes para que intenten conseguir un acuerdo que se adapte al club. Está es otra razón que enfatiza la importancia de que los agentes establezcan amistades dentro de los clubes ya que les da acceso y credibilidad para estar bien equipados para llevar a cabo el contrato. Si bien los agentes que representan jugadores siguen siendo los más comunes, al igual que los que representan directores técnicos, entrenadores; la aparición de agentes de clubes ha ampliado cada vez más el alcance de las demandas sobre la capacidad de los agentes de fútbol en la era moderna. A pesar de ello, los principios de la profesión siguen siendo los mismos; procurar y negociar un contrato en el mejor interés del cliente, ya sea para un jugador, club, o director técnico.

    Conclusión

    En este blog se ha explicado lo que significa ser un agente de fútbol, las diferencias entre los agentes tradicionales y el agente moderno. Ciertamente, para ser un agente exitoso hoy en día se necesita un rango de habilidades y conocimiento extenso, que permita que el agente opere y logre los mejores resultados posibles para sus clientes, ya sean jugadores o clubes.

    Es importante tener en cuenta que a pesar de que los agentes tengan conocimientos y habilidades en las extensas facetas en las que están involucrados los jugadores de fútbol modernos, es de gran importancia reconocer que, para poder ofrecer un mejor servicio a su cliente, el agente debe aprender y estar dispuesto a subcontratar a expertos para que hagan trabajos en ciertos campos. Esto es necesario particularmente para los jugadores ‘top.’ Formar un equipo adecuado a su alrededor para apoyar el rango de sus servicios. Por ejemplo, usar empresas especializadas en redes sociales, marketing, abogados y asesores financieros para mejorar el servicio que recibe el jugador. Todo esto siendo apoyado, construido y administrado por el agente, quien tiene un conocimiento sencillo de cada área especializada, por lo cual lo más probable es que solo brinde consejos preliminares básicos antes de contratar expertos.